العربية Get a quote

Technical guides

ABB vs Schneider Electric vs Siemens breakers: matching MCB, MCCB and ACB ranges

When a project names one maker and the site uses another, or a spare is needed for an older panel, the first question is which range matches. This guide puts the main MCB, MCCB and ACB families of ABB, Schneider Electric and Siemens side by side, and explains how to cross-reference a breaker safely.

By the Six Winds engineering team · Updated

Quick answer

At family level, ABB S200, Schneider Electric Acti9 iC60 and Siemens 5SL / 5SY are comparable MCB ranges; ABB Tmax XT, Schneider Electric ComPacT NSX and NS, and Siemens 3VA are comparable MCCB ranges; and ABB Emax 2, Schneider Electric MasterPacT MTZ and Siemens 3WA (3WL on older sites) are comparable ACB ranges. An exact equivalent must match rated current, poles, breaking capacity at the site voltage, trip unit, dimensions, mounting and accessories, confirmed from each maker’s data and approved by the engineer.

Step by step

  1. Read the existing breakerTake the full part number from the nameplate or the drawing, or a clear photo of the nameplate and the installed breaker.
  2. Find the family on the other makeUse the family table to find the comparable range by breaker type (MCB, MCCB or ACB) and current.
  3. Match the ratingsMatch rated current, poles, breaking capacity at the site voltage and the trip curve or trip unit type, from each maker’s data.
  4. Match the fitCheck frame dimensions, mounting (fixed, plug-in or withdrawable, DIN rail or plate), terminals and door cut-out.
  5. Match the accessoriesList the shunt trip, undervoltage release, auxiliary and alarm contacts, motor operator and handle, and check that each exists for the new breaker.
  6. Get the equivalent approvedSubmit the proposed equivalent with datasheets to the consultant or engineer, and order only after approval.

Matching ranges at family level

The table matches the main product families by breaker type. It is a family-level guide only: each family has many frames, ratings and versions, and exact equivalence must be confirmed from each maker’s data.

TypeABBSchneider ElectricSiemens
MCB (miniature circuit breaker)S200 seriesActi9 iC605SL / 5SY
MCCB (moulded case circuit breaker)Tmax XT (XT1 to XT7)ComPacT NSX (up to 630 A) and NS (larger frames)3VA (3VA1 smaller frames, 3VA2 larger frames)
ACB (air circuit breaker)Emax 2MasterPacT MTZ3WA (3WL on older sites)

Within one family, the breaking capacity, trip options and accessories differ by version, so two breakers from "matching" families can still be different products.

Why a family match is not a part match

Makers divide their ranges in different ways. One maker’s frame may cover a current band that another splits across two frames. Breaking capacity versions, trip unit options and pole layouts also differ. A breaker that matches on current alone can be the wrong size for the panel, the wrong breaking capacity for the fault level, or unable to take the accessories the circuit needs.

That is why a cross-reference starts from the full part number of the existing breaker, not from its current rating.

What must match

  • Rated current (In) and, for adjustable trip units, the setting range.
  • Poles: 1P, 2P, 3P or 4P, and whether the neutral is protected.
  • Breaking capacity at the site voltage: compare the ultimate (Icu) and service (Ics) breaking capacity at the actual system voltage from each maker’s data. It must be at least the prospective fault current at the point of installation.
  • Trip characteristic: the curve (B, C or D) for MCBs; thermal-magnetic or electronic trip unit, and its protection functions, for MCCBs and ACBs.
  • Standard: for example IEC 60898-1 or IEC 60947-2, as the specification asks.
  • Selectivity: where discrimination with upstream and downstream devices matters, check it from the makers’ tables; a new make can change it.

Dimensions, mounting and accessories

A replacement must fit the panel. Check the frame width, height and depth, the mounting (DIN rail, mounting plate, plug-in or withdrawable), the terminal type and cable connection, the door cut-out and the busbar or link connections. For withdrawable ACBs, the cradle is part of the match.

List every accessory on the existing breaker: shunt trip, undervoltage (UV) release, auxiliary and alarm contacts, motor operator, rotary or extended handle, interlocks and terminal covers. Check each one is available for the proposed breaker, with the same coil voltage. Accessories are rarely interchangeable between makes.

Approval of an equivalent

On a project, an equivalent from another maker is an engineering decision. It must be approved by the consultant or the responsible engineer before it is ordered or installed, usually through a material submittal with the datasheets of both breakers. On a running plant, the plant’s electrical engineer decides, taking into account selectivity, panel certification and spares policy.

Our quotations always mark an alternative as an alternative, with the maker, part number and datasheet, so the comparison can be checked.

What to send for a cross-reference

Send the existing part number, or a sharp photo of the nameplate and of the breaker installed in the panel, the accessories fitted, the system voltage and the fault level if known, and whether the same make is required or an equivalent is allowed. Our part number cross-reference tool gives a first match; we then confirm it against the makers’ data. E-mail sales@sixwinds.com.sa or use the quotation form.

Common questions

Which Schneider Electric MCCB matches ABB Tmax XT?

At family level, ComPacT NSX and NS are the comparable Schneider Electric MCCB ranges, and Siemens 3VA is the comparable Siemens range. The exact model must be matched on ratings, dimensions and accessories from each maker’s data.

Is Siemens 3WA the same as 3WL?

Both are Siemens ACB ranges; 3WA is the current range and 3WL is found on older sites. Check dimensions, cradle and accessories before replacing one with the other.

Can I replace a breaker by matching the ampere rating only?

No. Poles, breaking capacity at the site voltage, trip curve or trip unit, dimensions, mounting and accessories must all match, and the equivalent must be approved by the engineer.

Who approves an equivalent breaker?

On a project, the consultant or responsible engineer approves it, usually through a material submittal. On a running plant, the plant’s electrical engineer decides.

What do you need to cross-reference my breaker?

The existing part number or a clear photo of the nameplate and the installed breaker, the accessories fitted, and the system voltage and fault level if known.

Need these items? E-mail your list or a nameplate photo to sales@sixwinds.com.sa, or use the RFQ form.

This guide is general information. Final selection must follow the project design, the applicable standards and the maker's data.