Use an MCB for final circuits up to 125 A (lighting, sockets, small loads), an MCCB for feeders and sub-distribution from about 16 A to 1600 A, and an ACB for main incomers and large feeders from about 630 or 800 A up to 6300 A. In every case the breaking capacity (Icn for MCBs to IEC 60898-1, Icu and Ics for breakers to IEC 60947-2) must be at least the prospective fault current where the breaker is installed.
Step by step
- Find the design current and the fault levelTake the design current of the circuit from the load, and the prospective short-circuit current at the board from the designer or the single-line diagram. These two numbers decide most of the choice.
- Pick the family by current and roleFinal circuits up to 125 A: MCB. Feeders, motor feeders and sub-main boards from about 16 A to 1600 A: MCCB. Main incomers, generator and bus-coupler breakers from about 630 or 800 A up to 6300 A: ACB.
- Check the breaking capacity at your voltageThe kA value must be at least the fault level at that point, and it must be the value stated for your system voltage, for example 400 or 415 V. Prefer a breaker whose Ics, not only Icu, covers the fault level on important feeders.
- Choose the curve or the trip unitMCB: curve B, C or D by the load. MCCB: thermal-magnetic for simple feeders, electronic LSI or LSIG where you need adjustment, earth-fault protection or selectivity. ACB: electronic trip unit as standard.
- Check selectivity and temperatureConfirm from the maker's selectivity tables that the downstream breaker trips first, and check the maker's temperature derating if the panel runs hot.
- Write one clear RFQ line per breakerFamily, poles, rated current, breaking capacity at voltage, curve or trip unit, mounting, accessories and standard. Add the maker if the specification names one.
Three families, three jobs
All three are circuit breakers: they carry the load current, open on overload and short circuit, and can be switched by hand. The difference is size, breaking capacity, how adjustable the protection is, and where in the system they sit.
| MCB | MCCB | ACB | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical rated current | up to 125 A | about 16 A to 1600 A | about 630 or 800 A to 6300 A |
| Product standard | IEC 60898-1 (household and similar), some ranges to IEC 60947-2 | IEC 60947-2 | IEC 60947-2 |
| Breaking capacity term | Icn (and Ics) to IEC 60898-1 | Icu and Ics | Icu, Ics and the short-time withstand Icw |
| Protection | fixed thermal-magnetic, curve B, C or D | thermal-magnetic (fixed or adjustable) or electronic LSI/LSIG | electronic LSI/LSIG, fully adjustable |
| Mounting | 35 mm DIN rail | fixed, plug-in or draw-out; front or rear connection | fixed or draw-out, usually with motor-charged closing spring |
| Typical use | final circuits: lighting, sockets, small loads | feeders, motor feeders, sub-distribution boards, small incomers | main incomers, generator breakers, bus couplers, large feeders |
The ranges overlap. A 100 A circuit can take an MCB or an MCCB, and a 1000 A incomer can be a large MCCB or an ACB. In the overlap, the fault level, the need for adjustment, maintenance (draw-out) and the specification decide.
Breaking capacity: Icn, Icu and Ics
Breaking capacity is the largest short-circuit current the breaker can interrupt safely. It must be at least the prospective fault current where the breaker is installed. The terms depend on the standard the breaker is tested to:
- Icn (IEC 60898-1): the rated short-circuit capacity of an MCB for household and similar use. Common values are 4.5, 6 and 10 kA. The same standard also gives a service value Ics, which is lower than Icn on the higher ratings.
- Icu (IEC 60947-2): the rated ultimate short-circuit breaking capacity. After a fault at this level the breaker has done its job, but it may need to be inspected or replaced.
- Ics (IEC 60947-2): the rated service short-circuit breaking capacity, given as 25, 50, 75 or 100 % of Icu. After a fault at Ics the breaker must stay fit for normal service. On incomers and critical feeders, many specifications ask for Ics = 100 % Icu.
- Icw (IEC 60947-2, category B breakers, mainly ACBs): the short-time withstand current, the fault current the breaker can carry for a stated time without tripping, so that downstream breakers can clear the fault first.
The kA value always belongs to a voltage. A breaker can have one Icu at 230 V and a lower one at 415 V, so read the value at your system voltage.
Trip units: thermal-magnetic or electronic
A thermal-magnetic trip unit uses a bimetal for overload and a coil for short circuit. It is simple and suits most final circuits and many feeders. On MCBs both settings are fixed; on MCCBs the thermal setting, and sometimes the magnetic one, can be adjusted on many models.
An electronic trip unit measures the current with sensors and lets you set each protection function separately:
- L, long time: overload protection, set close to the cable or load rating.
- S, short time: short-circuit protection with a small time delay, used for selectivity.
- I, instantaneous: trips at once on high fault currents.
- G, ground fault: earth-fault protection, needed on many incomers by the specification.
LSI and LSIG units are standard on ACBs and common on larger MCCB frames. Some also measure energy and send data to a building or plant system; check the communication option in the maker's data if you need it.
MCB curves B, C and D
An MCB's curve sets the current at which the magnetic part trips without delay. IEC 60898-1 defines three:
- Curve B: above 3 to 5 times In. Resistive loads and long runs, where fault currents are low.
- Curve C: above 5 to 10 times In. General circuits, lighting with drivers, small motors. The usual choice.
- Curve D: above 10 to 20 times In. High inrush loads such as transformers, welding sets and motors started direct on line.
The thermal part of an IEC 60898-1 MCB is calibrated at 30 °C. In a hot panel it can trip below its rating, so check the maker's temperature derating for Saudi summer conditions.
Selectivity in one paragraph
Selectivity (also called discrimination) means that when a fault happens, only the breaker nearest to it opens and the rest of the system stays on. It is total when this holds up to the full fault level, and partial when it holds only up to a stated current. It depends on the trip curves, the current-limiting behaviour of the downstream breaker and, with ACBs, on the short-time delay and Icw. It cannot be judged from the ratings alone: confirm it from the maker's selectivity tables for the exact pair of breakers, which is easier when both levels come from the same maker's range.
What to put on an RFQ line
One line per breaker type, with everything that changes the part number:
- Family and standard: MCB to IEC 60898-1, or MCCB/ACB to IEC 60947-2.
- Poles: 1P, 1P+N, 2P, 3P or 4P.
- Rated current In, and the frame size if you know it.
- Breaking capacity at the system voltage, for example "Icu 50 kA at 415 V, Ics 100 %".
- Curve (B, C, D) or trip unit (thermal-magnetic, LSI, LSIG).
- Mounting: DIN rail, fixed, plug-in or draw-out; front or rear connection.
- Accessories: shunt trip or undervoltage release with coil voltage, auxiliary and alarm contacts, motor operator, rotary handle, terminal covers.
- The maker, if the specification names one, and whether an equivalent is acceptable.
Example: "MCCB 3P, In 250 A, Icu 50 kA at 415 V, electronic LSI, fixed, front connection, shunt trip 230 V AC, 1 auxiliary contact, IEC 60947-2". E-mail sales@sixwinds.com.sa or use the quotation form; a nameplate photo is enough for a replacement.
Common questions
Is an MCB to IEC 60947-2 the same as an MCCB?
No. It is still a DIN-rail MCB, but it is tested to the industrial standard, so its breaking capacity is given as Icu and Ics instead of Icn. It does not reach MCCB currents or adjustment.
What is the difference between Icu and Ics?
Icu is the highest fault current the breaker can interrupt; it may then need replacing. Ics is the fault current it can interrupt and stay fit for service, stated as a percentage of Icu.
Can an MCCB be the main incomer instead of an ACB?
Yes, when the incomer current is within the MCCB range and its breaking capacity and selectivity suit the board. ACBs are chosen for higher currents, draw-out maintenance, short-time withstand and full trip adjustment.
Which MCB curve should I use for a motor?
Curve D, or curve C for small motors with a low starting current. For most motors a motor protection circuit breaker or an MCCB with a motor trip unit protects better.
Why does the kA rating change with voltage?
Interrupting an arc is harder at higher voltage, so the same breaker has a lower breaking capacity at 415 V than at 230 V. Always compare the value at your system voltage.
Need these items? E-mail your list or a nameplate photo to sales@sixwinds.com.sa, or use the RFQ form.
This guide is general information. Final selection must follow the project design, the applicable standards and the maker's data.
